Single-Pass Vs. Multi-Stroke: The Ins and Outs of Honing

Published 4/13/2012

Single-Pass Vs. Multi-Stroke: The Ins and Outs of Honing

Two principal honing processes are available. It’s important to choose the right one for the application requirements.

Dennis Westhoff, Sunnen Products

Compressor bodies, because of bore length and surface finish requirements, are typically honed with the multi-stroke process.

Piston pumps used in hydraulic flight control systems have clearances of 0.005 mm between moving parts, requiring precise bore size, roundness and straightness. The photo shows wobble pump bodies in a multi-spindle honing machine equipped with air gaging stations between spindles. This machine can control bore size to within 0.00025 mm.

Here is a single-pass honing tool. The powder-metal part has a relatively short but segmented bore, making it ideal for single-pass honing. The machine produces more than 4,000 parts per day with 50-micron roundness and 80-micron total tolerance.

A short bore makes rocker arms ideal for single-pass honing.

With higher performance required from turbochargers, steering knuckles, gears, fuel systems and valves, honing is being used more widely. It can make an already “good” bore into one that is round and straight to a fine degree of precision, with high process capability and accuracy measured in tenths of a micron. However, with two principal honing processes available—single-pass and conventional multi-stroke—it’s important to match the capabilities of each to the application requirements.

Different Processes

Multi-stroke honing is the more flexible and capable process because it uses “smart” tooling under servo control. The reciprocating abrasive tool with expanding stone assemblies can be controlled in size with accuracy of 0.000001 inch. Feed force of the abrasive can also be servo controlled. With the exception of diamond plated tools, the abrasives used in multi-stroke honing are self-dressing. A multi-stroke tool can be custom designed with different abrasive lengths and widths to handle blind, ported bores or landed bores. Finally, multi-stroke honing produces a pronounced and uniform crosshatch pattern on the bore surface that can be finely controlled to produce consistent, specific surface parameters that affect part wear, lubrication, lifespan, noise and more.

Single-pass honing machines use a series of progressively larger diamond mandrels with a fixed diameter and grit size. The abrasives are not self-dressing. Single-pass honing tools rotate while making one stroke in and out of the bore, though servo-controlled stroking provides some flexibility with adjustable speed and various feed profiles, such as pecking, short stroke and dwell. Single-pass honing is limited in the part configurations and materials it can process. Parts with L/D ratios up to 1:1 are ideal. Single-pass bore sizing also works with splined bores or longer L/D ratios if cross holes or other bore interruptions allow chip flushing. The process can mimic, but not duplicate, the crosshatch pattern produced by multi-stroke honing—a critical difference for some parts. With diameters below 0.300 inch, tool strength becomes a limitation.

Whether to use a single-stroke or multi-stroke honing process can sometimes be a clear-cut choice. For example, a blind bore, unless there is a large clearance at the bottom, always requires a multi-stroke process. In other situations, various factors affect the decision, including:

Part Materials

Multi-stroke honing works with almost any material, including the hardest steels, alnico, zinc, carbide, ceramic and plastics. With controllable cutting action, it can better control chip size, even for stringy chips.

Single-pass honing is fine for cast iron, powder metals, ceramic, glass, graphite and other free-cutting materials, but does not work well with extremely hard or soft materials. In general, materials that produce a long, stringy chip will not work well with single-pass honing.

Straightness Correction

Multi-stroke honing can straighten a bore with camber error (banana shape), particularly for parts with an L/D greater than 1:1. The abrasive is often sized to bridge the camber in the workpiece to machine it out.

In a part with camber, the sizing land on a single-pass tool follows the bore, so the geometry error usually cannot be corrected. Special-purpose single-pass tools with much longer sizing lands also have limited success reducing camber compared to multi-stroke honing.

L/D Ratio

Multi-stroke honing can be used with most L/D ratios. Parts with short bores, such as connecting rods, can even be stacked for higher productivity.

Single-pass honing is less suitable for parts with L/D exceeding 1:1, unless the part has interruptions through which chips can be flushed.

Stock Removal

A multi-stroke honing tool, depending on its size and design, can be adjusted over a large diameter range. For example, a 6-inch tool may have a half-inch range of expansion. This is the theoretical removal potential of the tool. In some applications, such as oilfield equipment, stock removal of several inches is common.

The chip clearance between the surfaces of the tool’s abrasive bond and the workpiece determines stock removal rates for single-pass honing, which is then limited by the degree of taper used on the diamond mandrel, typically from 0.001 to 0.005 inches. Stock removal also depends on the part’s material, hardness and geometry.

Surface Texture

Lubricant retention on the part’s bore surface is critical for many applications. When surface finish parameters must be reproduced accurately, along with a specific crosshatch angle, multi-stroke honing is the only choice.

The majority of the cutting in single-pass honing occurs on the down stroke. This produces a helical bore texture with little change to the surface on the upstroke, even with final reciprocation of the tool. This helical surface is unacceptable in many applications.

Surface Finish

If either process looks suitable but the parts need a consistent surface finish over the life of the abrasives, single-pass honing will be unsuitable because the abrasives are not self-dressing. With few exceptions, multi-pass honing uses self-dressing abrasives, so fresh, sharp grit is always being exposed.

Single-pass diamond tools produce a larger burr, because as the diamond grit dulls, final surface finish changes over time. The surface finish tends to become smoother as the grit dulls. The single-pass tool will also require much more power and torque to cut as it wears, similar to a worn drill bit or reamer.

About the Author: Dennis Westhoff is global business development manager with honing systems and tooling provider Sunnen Products.

Related Content

Machining Centers 12 Jun 2024

Orthopedic Event Discusses Manufacturing Strategies

At the seminar, representatives from multiple companies discussed strategies for making orthopedic devices accurately and efficiently.

How to Mitigate Chatter to Boost Machining Rates

There are usually better solutions to chatter than just reducing the feed rate. Through vibration analysis, the chatter problem can be solved, enabling much higher metal removal rates, better quality and longer tool life.

Automation 11 Aug 2023

Inside the Premium Machine Shop Making Fasteners

AMPG can’t help but take risks — its management doesn’t know how to run machines. But these risks have enabled it to become a runaway success in its market.

Lean Approach to Automated Machine Tending Delivers Quicker Paths to Success

Almost any shop can automate at least some of its production, even in low-volume, high-mix applications. The key to getting started is finding the simplest solutions that fit your requirements. It helps to work with an automation partner that understands your needs.

Automation

Why We Ask Machine Shop Leaders to Speak at TASC – The Automated Shop Conference

TASC is our industry’s premier peer-to-peer automation stage where America’s shop leaders refine the art of metalworking and CNC machining. For conference speakers, it's also an opportunity to showcase your skills and gain exposure for your business. Here are five why stepping into the spotlight at TASC could be your smartest move toward elevating your shop.

View From My Shop

Shop Tour Video: You've Never Seen a Manufacturing Facility Like This

In the latest installment of our “View From My Shop” series, explore Marathon Precision’s multi-process approach to manufacturing, where blacksmiths and hand-forged dies meet state-of-the-art CNC machining. Discover how restoring classic muscle cars and building custom art projects creates a dynamic shop culture — and draws top talent to this unique and innovative metalworking facility.

Shop Management Software

Setting Up the Building Blocks for a Digital Factory

Woodward Inc. spent over a year developing an API to connect machines to its digital factory. Caron Engineering’s MiConnect has cut most of this process while also granting the shop greater access to machine information.

91��Ƶ��վ��

Single-Pass Vs. Multi-Stroke: The Ins and Outs of Honing

Share

Related Content

Orthopedic Event Discusses Manufacturing Strategies

How to Mitigate Chatter to Boost Machining Rates

Inside the Premium Machine Shop Making Fasteners

Lean Approach to Automated Machine Tending Delivers Quicker Paths to Success

Read Next

Why We Ask Machine Shop Leaders to Speak at TASC – The Automated Shop Conference

Shop Tour Video: You've Never Seen a Manufacturing Facility Like This

Setting Up the Building Blocks for a Digital Factory

Country

Industries Served

Operations Performed

Welcome to 91��Ƶ��վ��!

Single-Pass Vs. Multi-Stroke: The Ins and Outs of Honing

Share

HEIDENHAIN CORPORATION

Featured Content

QualiChem Inc.

Featured Content

Featured Videos

Mikron Corp.

Featured Content

Featured Videos

SMW Autoblok Corporation

Featured Content

Featured Videos

ZEISS Industrial Quality Solutions

Featured Content

Featured Videos

T J Davies, Co., Inc.

Featured Content

CNC Engineering, Inc.

Featured Content

Featured Videos

Related Content

Read Next

Country

Industries Served

Operations Performed

Welcome to 91��Ƶ��վ��!